This case study is based on an actual engagement with a Cerity Partners client. Facts and identifying details have been altered, generalized, or omitted to protect client confidentiality. This client’s experience is not representative of the experience of other clients and should not be viewed as an indication or guarantee of similar results. This description does not constitute a testimonial or endorsement of Cerity Partners’ advisory services.

The situation

A corporate executive had accumulated a significant position in the publicly traded stock of the company where they had spent much of their career.

The stock had appreciated substantially and represented a large percentage of the family’s investable assets and total wealth. In addition, the family’s income, deferred compensation, retirement benefits, and future equity awards were connected to the same company.

The family wanted to explore ways to reduce its exposure to a single company while recognizing that an immediate sale of the entire position could result in a substantial capital-gains tax liability.

The family asked our team to evaluate the available alternatives and help develop a framework for making an informed diversification plan over time.

The planning considerations

The analysis involved several competing objectives:

  • Reducing company-specific investment risk;
  • Evaluating the potential tax consequences of selling appreciated shares;
  • Maintaining sufficient liquidity for anticipated spending;
  • Preserving flexibility as the family’s circumstances evolve;
  • Coordinating investment decisions with charitable and estate-planning objectives;
  • Understanding the costs, risks, restrictions, and potential benefits of each strategy; and
  • Accounting for employer trading policies and applicable securities-law restrictions.

No single strategy addressed every consideration. Each alternative involved trade-offs related to liquidity, taxes, investment risk, cost, complexity, and control.

Our process

We began by reviewing the family’s overall financial circumstances, including:

  • The concentrated stock position;
  • Other investment accounts;
  • Expected future equity compensation;
  • Cash-flow requirements;
  • Charitable intentions;
  • Existing estate-planning structures;
  • Risk tolerance;
  • Time horizon;
  • Liquidity needs; and
  • Tax circumstances.

Working with the family’s tax and legal advisors, we then evaluated several potential approaches.

The purpose of the analysis was not to recommend a particular strategy in isolation. Instead, it was to compare the available strategies and determine whether one or a combination of approaches might be appropriate based on the family’s objectives and circumstances.

Strategies evaluated

Exchange funds

An exchange fund may allow an eligible investor to contribute appreciated stock in exchange for an interest in a diversified investment portfolio.

This approach may provide immediate diversification without requiring a taxable sale of the contributed shares. However, exchange funds generally involve significant holding periods, limited liquidity, eligibility requirements, fees, investment restrictions, and other risks.

At the end of the applicable holding period, an investor may receive a portfolio of appreciated securities rather than cash. Participation does not eliminate the embedded tax liability; rather, it may defer the gain and change the investment into which that gain is embedded.

Integrated tax-aware long-short strategy

We evaluated an integrated strategy in which an investment manager would manage a long-short portfolio funded with cash, diversified securities, proceeds from sales of the concentrated position, or a portion of the concentrated position itself.

A long-short strategy may seek to provide market exposure while creating additional opportunities to harvest capital losses. Those losses may potentially be used to offset realized capital gains, including gains from the sale of the concentrated stock, subject to applicable tax rules and the investor’s individual circumstances.

Market-neutral tax overlay

We also reviewed an overlay structure in which the client would maintain a collateral portfolio invested in exchange-traded funds, mutual funds, or other diversified investments while a separate manager operated a market-neutral long-short strategy.

An overlay may create additional opportunities for tax-loss harvesting while allowing the client to retain the underlying collateral portfolio.

Tax-aware direct indexing

A tax-aware direct-indexing strategy was evaluated as a potential destination for proceeds from future stock sales.

Direct indexing generally involves owning individual securities intended to approximate the characteristics of a selected market index. Because the investor owns the underlying securities, the manager may be able to harvest losses in individual positions while maintaining broad market exposure.

Options-based overlay strategies

Options-based strategies were also considered. Depending on the structure, an options strategy may be used to seek downside protection, generate income, or establish a more disciplined framework for reducing concentrated-stock exposure in a less tax burdensome way.

Charitable planning

For a family with charitable goals, donating appreciated securities directly to a qualified charitable organization or donor-advised fund may be considered.

Depending on the donor’s circumstances and applicable tax law, a charitable contribution of appreciated securities may provide an income-tax deduction and may avoid recognition of capital gain on the donated shares.

Estate-planning strategies

The family’s estate-planning attorney, in conjunction with qualified legal and tax professionals, also reviewed whether transfers of selected shares to trusts or other estate-planning structures might be appropriate.

Such transfers may shift future appreciation outside of the transferor’s taxable estate, depending on the structure and applicable law. However, estate-planning strategies may involve gift taxes, use of available exemptions, valuation considerations, loss of control, administrative requirements, and other legal and tax consequences.

The planning framework

After reviewing the alternatives, the family and its advisors developed a multiyear framework that could include a combination of strategies rather than reliance on a single solution.

Potential components included:

  • Establishing concentration limits and periodic review points;
  • Selling portions of the position over time;
  • Evaluating an exchange fund for a portion of the shares;
  • Reinvesting sale proceeds into a diversified, tax-aware portfolio;
  • Considering long-short or overlay strategies to pursue additional tax-management opportunities;
  • Evaluating options strategies for selected shares retained during the transition;
  • Donating appreciated shares as part of the family’s charitable plan;
  • Coordinating any trust transfers with the family’s estate-planning attorney; and
  • Adjusting the strategy as tax laws, market conditions, liquidity needs, or family circumstances changed.

The final approach depended on the family’s objectives, risk tolerance, tax circumstances, and willingness to accept the respective features associated with each strategy.

The role of the wealth advisor

Concentrated-stock planning often requires coordination among investment, tax, estate-planning, charitable, and risk-management professionals.

Our role is to help clients:

  • Identify the relevant planning considerations;
  • Evaluate multiple strategies in relation to their planning objectives;
  • Understand the advantages, disadvantages, costs, and risks of each alternative;
  • Coordinate implementation with the client’s legal and tax advisors; and
  • Monitor the plan as circumstances change.

The appropriate approach will vary for every client. In some cases, a straightforward sale and reinvestment may be the most suitable strategy. In other cases, a combination of strategies working in tandem may warrant consideration.

The goal is not to minimize taxes at all costs. It is to make informed decisions that balance diversification, liquidity, risk, taxes, complexity, and long-term family objectives. For more information, visit our practice page or call 312-715-3814.


Cerity Partners, LLC (“Cerity Partners”) is an SEC-registered investment adviser with offices across the United States. Registration as an investment adviser does not imply any level of skill or training. The information provided is not intended as personalized investment, tax, or legal advice. There is no guarantee that any opinions, projections, or views expressed will materialize. You should consult a qualified professional before making financial decisions. Information is subject to change without notice and is believed to be reliable but is not guaranteed. For Cerity Partners’ registration status, please visit the Investment Adviser Public Disclosure website at www.adviserinfo.sec.gov. For additional details about our services, fees, or potential conflicts of interest, please request our disclosure statement, including Form CRS and ADV Part 2, using the contact information provided.

Please read important disclosures here.